ThyssenKrupp Access Home Page Accessibility Division Home Page ThyssenKrupp Access
Home Customer Resource Center Architect/Builder Resource Center Dealer Resource Center Locations Site Map
Stair Lifts Wheelchair Lifts Elevators About Us Contact Us ThyssenKrupp

Search
Request Info
AdTrack Link
Direct Sales Offices
Residential Elevator Site
Wheelchair Lifts
PL-RA Residential
PL-S Standard
PL-TG ToeGuard
PL-ENC Enclosure
PL-EZE Enclosure
PL-P Portable
Carrier Lift
Financing

FAQ

Case Studies
Home
Wheelchair Lifts - Case Studies

Wheelchair Lifts - Lifts VS. Ramps

Wheelchair Lifts offers the solution to a wide variety of your accessibility problems

Imagine that you arrive for work one day and your office building is suspended several feet above the ground. As you look upward, a feeling of helplessness overwhelms you because there is not a way for you to enter the building.

Sound far-fetched? Actually, it's not. This is the real-life dilemma disable people and people with mobility challenges confront on a daily basis. Buildings that do not provide access alternatives for people with disabilities might just as well be suspended 10 feet above the ground.

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), signed into law on July 26, 1990, is changing this situation. Effective January 26, 1992, commercial facilities were required by law to be accessible to people with disabilities. To accomplish this goal, most buildings in the United States have several options - vertical platform (wheelchair) lifts, ramps or elevators. When selecting one of these alternatives, several factors should be considere3d: cost, space limitations, aesthetics, upkeep, ease of use, achieveability, building size and travel distance.

Ramp GraphElevators are a viable solution in certain applications, such as heavy-duty, multi-level, interior settings. However, for shorter vertical rises, whether they are interior or exterior, they are often too costly and space prohibitive. Because such settings represent a large share of the accessibility problems in the real world, we have limited the following comparison to lifts and ramps.

A closer look at both ramps and lifts identifies some key differences.

Lifts Versus Ramps
While ramps may seem to provide a simple, straightforward solution to any accessibility problem, upon further analysis it becomes clear that in most cases the reverse is actually the case.

Whether it is an interior or an exterior accessibility compliance issue, ramps like elevators, require extensive space, are expensive, are hard for disabled people to use and can have poor aesthetics.

The ADAAG (Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines) are very specific about the use of ramps, and federal, state and local regulations governing the use of ramps abound. For instance, the angle of a ramp is referred to as the "slope." The slope is defined by the ratio of the vertical rise to the horizontal run. Since the slope of a ramp may not exceed 1:12 in order to comply, for every inch a ramp rises, it must include at least 12 inches of run or surface.

In addition, all landings must have a minimum clear length of 60 inches, and where a ramp changes direction, the landing must provide for at least 60 x 60 inches of clearance. Landings must be provided every 30 feet of ramp run for resting, at each turn, and at the top of the ramp to assist in the negotiation of doors and entrances.

Platform lifts, on the other hand, are better than ramps in nearly all areas - cost, space efficiency, maintenance and aesthetics. With a host of design and format options available, lift systems can be installed in anything from woodframe enclosures, like small elevators, to free-standing, attractive, atrium-style enclosures.

A Well-kept Secret
An often-asked question is, "If wheelchair lifts are so good, why aren't they more widely known?" There are two major reasons for this misconception.

First, few people are aware that platform lifts exist. Secondly, most people do not understand how lifts can be used and integrated into a variety of architectural surroundings.

The fact is that lifts have been successfully solving accessibility problems in the United States for more than 20 years, in a wide range of applications. As more and more people become aware of the important benefits that wheelchairs lifts deliver in a great many different applications, the popularity of these versatile and efficient system will grow accordingly.

Even those who are aware of wheelchair lifts often incorrectly assume that ramps would be less expensive. The accompanying graph (Figure 1) shows the initial costs of a wheelchair lift as compared to that of a ramp. Initial costs include all materials and estimated labor of installed lifts and ramps.

As the graph demonstrated, the initial costs of lifts are far easier to control than those of ramps. As the vertical rise increases, initial ramp costs quickly outpace those for a wheelchair lift.

Ramp costs are bases on a standard concrete ramp structure with steel handrails, built to ADAAG specifications. Lift costs are based on a "toe-guard telescoping" style wheelchair lift.

Ramp Illustration Ramp Illustration Ramp Illustration

Figures 2, 3 and 4 demonstrate how a ramp and a wheelchair lift could be utilized to solve a particular accessibility problem. While both would solve the problem, it is easy to see the different space and aesthetic consequences of the two.

The "Before" illustration, Figure 2, represents a typical commercial facility with an obvious accessibility problem of stairs leading to a facility entrance. Figure 3 shows how a concrete ramp with steel handrails could be installed at the facility; while Figure 4 represents a wheelchair lift in the same setting.More specifically, Figure 4 shows a telescoping style wheelchair lift. A series of panels surrounds the lift on the outside and remains on the ground. A second series of panels surrounds the platform, raising and lowering with the platform as the user travels. While a variety of lifts are available, a telescoping style wheelchair lift is used in this example because it is the type most often specified for its superior versatility, attractive appearance and all-around operating efficiencies.

Figure 5 compares not only the initial costs, but also the other major considerations of space, aesthetics and upkeep in making an accessibility decision. Here again, the advantages that lifts have over ramps are plain to see.

The Best Overall Solution
People evaluating accessibility alternatives need to keep in mind that the wheelchair lifts they consider should be manufactured to meet the ADA, as well as specific federal, state and local codes. While cutting corners to provide a "quick fix" may appear attractive up front, the ongoing implications of such an approach can prove to be detrimental. Considerable thought should be given to committing the necessary resources from the very beginning, in order to provide the best and most cost-effective short-term as well as long-term results.

When all factors are considered, more and more people are realizing that wheelchair lifts are indeed the best solution to accessibility problems in almost all situations.

 

Wheelchair Lifts

Ramps

Initial Cost

$8,000 Range

$10,000 Range

Space Required

5' x 5' area (25 sq ft)

3' x 36' ramp plus a 5' x 5' mid-landing (approx. 133 sq ft)

Aesthetics

Blends into existing environment with minor modifictions

Very difficult to incorporate into surroundings with expensive modifications

Maintenance

Requires periodic routine maintenance, highly weather resistant finishes protect equipment; mechanical cabinet with UL label

Requires routine maintenance / upkeep concrete repair, painting of ramps / sides / handrails and snow / debris removal


When considering an accessibility solution, space requirements, aesthetics and maintenance, as well as initial costs, should all be considered in order to arrive at the most effective short-term and long-term solution. The comparison above is based on a 30 inch vertical rise.

ADA - Compliance or Defiance





Home
Customer Resource Center | Architect/Builder Resource Center | Dealer Resource Center
Locations | About Us | Contact Us | Site Map
Stair Lifts | Wheelchair Lifts | LU/LA Elevators

A company of ThyssenKrupp Elevator
Privacy Policy
©2009 ThyssenKrupp Access
Produced and Developed by Digital Lagoon